Wine, Words & Wednesday, No. 12

Who's up for an algae smoothie??
Who’s up for an algae smoothie??

I’ve been thinking a lot about water this week. Kind of a surprise, really, since I usually think a lot about wine.  Call it my out-of-the-box moment.

My parents live in northern Ohio, near Toledo.  Earlier this week, the Toledo area was under a water ban (don’t drink, bathe or boil) because of a Lake Erie algae bloom containing dangerous levels of microcystin, a toxin released by cyanobacteria, which is a fancy science word for blue-green algae. Microcystin isn’t very nice.  If you swim in it, you’re in for an itchy rash, hives and blisters. If you swallow the stuff, it can cause a whole range of nasty gastrointestinal issues, along with potential liver and kidney damage.  Oh, and it’s been known to kill pets and livestock.

So when the Lake Erie science guys issue a CAPSLOCK warning that says, “DON’T DRINK THE WATER!” . . . Copy that.

Algae blooms aren’t a new thing for Lake Erie — they happen almost every summer.  Some blooms are more toxic than others.  Lake Erie is more susceptible to the algae blooms because it’s a shallow lake (only around 24 feet deep near Toledo), and warms quickly.  Toxic algae loves shallow, warm lakes.  The algae blooms can be traced back to phosphorous run-off from fertilizer and animal waste.  Climate change and a couple species of invasive mussels are also getting a share of the blame.  Unfortunately, this isn’t Lake Erie’s first time at the Algae Bloom Rodeo, and it won’t be their last.

Lake Erie has never had a great reputation.  For years, people have whispered it’s a dead, dirty lake.  I’ve heard the word sewer tossed around, too.  Lake Erie rebounded a bit over the last couple of decades, but still wrestles with that reputation.  When I was a kid, I swam in Lake Erie almost every summer, an activity I now realize is about the same as taking a dip in a petri dish. Back then, there were none of these handy public advisory signs posted on the beaches. Honestly, it’s a wonder I haven’t sprouted a third ear.

buckeye lake 1
Come on in . . . the water is fine.

My mom said it was impossible to to buy bottled water in northern Ohio this past weekend — the store shelves were (and still are) bare.  (This is the part where the Doomsday Preppers start to look like geniuses).  And you can’t boil water contaminated with microcystin.  Well, you can, but boiling only concentrates the toxins and increases your chances of going twelve rounds with Lake Erie Dysentery.

So what did my folks do in the face of this public health crisis?  They drank wine!

My parents have a wine cellar capable of sustaining them through any algae bloom Lake Erie can throw at them.  Which brings me (finally) to this week’s words:

bacteria-JPG-73These words are frequently attributed to Benjamin Franklin, but as such they’re almost assuredly a misquote.  Either that, or Benjamin Franklin was an oracle.  The word Bacterium wasn’t introduced until 1828, and the word Bacteria wasn’t used as a scientific term until 1838. Benjamin Franklin died in 1790.  I’ve also seen the words attributed to David Auerbach (no idea which one)  and someone named “Old German Saying”.

I’ve even seen these words as an addendum to Pliny’s very famous quote, “In wine there is truth.”  It makes sense.  The ancient Greeks & Romans knew there were baddies in the water, so they drank a ton of wine instead.  And whatever water they did drink, they mixed with wine, thinking the wine would somehow make the water less poisonous.  But they still wouldn’t have used the word bacteria.

Regardless of the source, the next time Lake Erie blooms with toxic algae, I’m comforted in the knowledge that my parents have plenty of wisdom and strength to drink while they wait for the all clear sign.


P.S.  On Monday, officials lifted the water ban after deciding toxin levels in Lake Erie had returned to “acceptable levels”.  This means the water probably doesn’t contain enough toxin to kill your poodle.


  1. Since my daughter has decided to attend Ohio State University the marching band director has been fired amongst sexual harassment allegations and now the drinking water is contaminated. I am thinking this is all a very bad sign!


    1. Is your daughter marching? I can only imagine the tension in TBBITL right now. I suspect there’s more to this than we know. On both sides. Hopefully the H20 in Columbus doesn’t source from Lake Erie!!


      1. Thankfully she decided to wait till her Sophomore year to march. Just hope the problems are resolved and the environment changes within the band or she will have to wait longer.


  2. Well, I think our rivers in NYC would rival Lake Eerie’s less than stellar reputation for toxins in the water, The Hudson and East River are well know for being particularly putrid. Oh geez, that is actually water from Lake Eerie, ugh, thats a whole lotta algae.


  3. Glad to hear that all is still well with your family in light of having been slimed! I spent many years up on Lake Erie in Cleveland (you know, where the Cuyahoga River actually caught fire all those years ago), and you do have to kinda be ready of anything up there. The important lesson here is that always keep a LOT of wine on hand, because 1) its usually safe to drink (in moderation, of course), 2) alcohol often kills yucky things, and 3) I’ve never encountered a bottle of wine with an algae bloom in it.


  4. I used to swim in Lake Erie, too, when I was a kid, but that was before it was ‘fire-catching’ filthy. At least that’s what my mother told me. I’m very glad to hear your parents are well-stocked in strength and wisdom.


  5. I had the same thoughts about the water and wine, since I live in the Detroit area. Most of our stores up here were having trouble keeping bottled water on the shelves. I have many memories of swimming in Lake Erie, but up on the Canadian shores. Just keep your cellar stocked and you will be fine.


  6. My recent trip to California and many chats there with winery staff about the drought has me thinking a lot more about water these days. Funny how we take some things for granted in life… We’d have plenty of wine to make it through a short one, but I don’t know how well I’d be functioning after a few days – lol!


    1. I had that same thought more than a couple of times while writing this post — we really do take safe water for granted. I’m starting to think about building a water cellar next to my wine cellar . . . Cheers!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s